Evidence Based Decisions in child neglect: evaluation of a new approach to assessment What works in improving decision-making for families where there are concerns about child neglect

Hands on tableThe Evidence Based Decisions (EBD) service aims to support social workers to make the right decision at the right time when working with families where there are concerns about child neglect. NSPCC practitioners worked in partnership with local authority social workers using the North Carolina Family Assessment Scale (NCFAS-G) to focus on improving evidence, understanding and decision-making. 

This report describes the different ways the EBD review was used and looks at how and why it differs from everyday practice. It is part of our Impact and evidence series.

Author: Mike Williams
Published: 2015

Social workers felt the review helped them make the right decisions for families: with 94% of the surveys returned, the professional felt that the review had influenced decisions.

Professionals found the following features of the EBD helpful:

  • requirement to be evidence-based - the EBD review required a score in each area of family-functioning and an explanation for how the data fit the scoring criteria
  • professional challenge –  the social worker and NSPCC practitioner were able to question and challenge each other about data underpinning their scores for family functioning
  • more time given to the family -  time dedicated to the review gave social workers more time to observe parent-child interactions in the home
  • focus on parenting strengths as well as weaknesses.

Some social workers said NCFAS-G provided more concrete evidence than assessments they commonly used, such as the Common Assessment Framework (CAF) triangle, and led to a more accurate assessment.

Joint working helped improve the quality of evidence and understanding. Whilst one practitioner talked to the parents, the other practitioner was able to focus on listening.

Sometimes issues such as workload or a lack of focus on identifying the key concerns relevant to neglect influenced social workers’ ability to get the most out of the review.

Some social workers felt that having the support of the NSPCC on a way forward gave them confidence to argue for a decision.

The usefulness of the EBD review was sometimes limited if social workers already had evidence and a good understanding of what was happening with a family.

Next steps

The learning from this evaluation will be further developed in the new NSPCC service Thriving Families.

"You can see the children come in; the girl is wearing plimsolls, in winter, at school. It's those tiny points that you miss when you're looking at the big points … and it’s the tiny points that actually really matter … I think that's what this assessment does."

"To be completely honest [if we hadn't used the EBD review] I don't think we would have been able to identify the neglect that's within the family. I found it quite powerful."

Please cite as: Williams, M. (2015) Evidence Based Decisions in child neglect: an evaluation of an exploratory approach to assessment using the North Carolina Family Assessment Scale. London: NSPCC.

Impact and evidence hub

Find out how we evaluate and research the impact we’re making in protecting children, get tips and tools for researchers and access resources.

Our impact and evidence

Impact and evidence series

Our evaluation and research reports that look at the impact of our services or summarise the evidence about what works to protect children from abuse and neglect.

Find out more

Looking for something in particular?

Our Information Service can help you find the latest policy, practice and research in child protection.

Call 0808 800 5000 or email help@nspcc.org.uk for more information.

Submit an enquiry

Related resources

Spotlight on preventing child neglect

What works in preventing child neglect. Part of the NSPCC’s Impact and evidence series.
Find out more

Neglect and its relationship to other forms of harm

Findings from 3 linked evidence scopes investigating the relationship between child neglect and other forms of maltreatment. Makes evidence-based recommendations for policy and practice.
Find out more

Thriving communities: a framework for preventing and intervening early in child neglect

Concrete actions for national and local decision-makers and commissioners to help stop child neglect.
Find out more

Realising the potential: tackling child neglect in universal services

Sets out a model showing the way universal services practitioners can provide effective early help for child neglect.
Find out more

Hurting inside: learning from the NSPCC helpline and Childline on neglect

What children are telling us about living with neglect and key statistics on contacts to our helplines about child neglect. 
Find out more

Neglect and serious case reviews

A systematic analysis of neglect in serious case reviews in England, between 2003 and 2011.
Find out more

Child abuse and neglect in the UK today

Research report into children’s experiences of abuse and neglect.
Find out more

Evidence Based Decisions

Reviewing family situations to protect children at risk of harm.
Evidence Based Decisions service

Thriving Families

Helping to define, detect and tackle neglect and provide the right support for families.
Thriving Families service

Graded Care Profile

Assessing the care of children and identifying neglect.
Graded Care Profile service

SafeCare

Encouraging, informing and promoting better parenting to protect young children from harm.
SafeCare service

Improving parenting, improving practice

Helping parents who are struggling to care for their children.
Improving parenting, improving practice service

Neglect or emotional abuse in teenagers: Core info leaflet

Leaflet on what is currently known about teenagers’ experiences of neglect and emotional harm. Part of the Core info leaflet series.
Find out more

Emotional neglect and emotional abuse in pre-school children: Core info leaflet

Leaflet summarising what we currently know about children under 6 who have been emotionally neglected or abused. Part of the Core info leaflet series.
Find out more

Neglect or emotional abuse in children aged 5-14: Core info leaflet

A leaflet summarising how neglect and emotional abuse affects children aged 5 to 14. Part of the Core info leaflet series.
Find out more

Neglect

Neglect is the ongoing failure to meet a child's basic needs. It's dangerous and children can suffer serious and long-term harm.
Read more about neglect

Emotional abuse

Children who are emotionally abused suffer emotional maltreatment or neglect. It's sometimes called psychological abuse and can cause children serious harm.
Read more about emotional abuse

CASPAR

Our Current Awareness Service for Practice, Policy And Research delivers free weekly email alerts to keep you up-to-date with all the latest safeguarding and child protection news.

Sign up to CASPAR

Information Service

Our free service for people who work with children can help you find the latest policy, practice, research and news on child protection and related subjects.

For more information, call us or email help@nspcc.org.uk.

0808 800 5000

Submit an enquiry

Support our research

Research like this helps keep children safe from abuse – but we can’t do it without our generous supporters. 

Donate now

Follow @NSPCCpro

Follow us on Twitter and keep up-to-date with all the latest news in child protection.

Follow @NSPCCpro on Twitter

Library catalogue

We hold the UK's largest collection of child protection resources and the only UK database specialising in published material on child protection, child abuse and child neglect.

Search the library

New in the Library

A free weekly email listing all of the new child protection publications added to our library collection.

Sign up to New in the Library

Helping you keep children safe

Read our guide for professionals on what we do and the ways we can work with you to protect children and prevent abuse and neglect.

Read our guide (PDF)

Impact and evidence hub

Find out how we evaluate and research the impact we’re making in protecting children, get tips and tools for researchers and access resources.

Our impact and evidence

Get expert training and consultancy

Grow your child protection knowledge and skills with CPD certified courses delivered by our experts nationwide and online.
Get expert training

Sharing knowledge to keep children safe

Read our guide to NSPCC Knowledge and Information Services to find out how we can help you with child protection queries, support your research, and help you learn and develop.

Read our guide (PDF)